The 4th Condition Encompasses Fives Others
 
1.      The 5th condition, Absolute Continuity Condition (Samanantara-paccayo), is entirely the same as this 4th Condition. This Absolute Continuity puts emphasis on how dense our mental processes are. 
2.      The 12th condition, Repetition Condition (Āsevana-paccayo), also deals with the mental processes, in which the preceding mind-moments of javana contribute their succeeding ones. They are fully active and so powerful that they can leave behind such dormant forms of their energies as kamma, pāramī, etc. by means of Repetition Condition.

3.      The 22nd condition, Absence Condition (Natthi-paccayo), is also all about preceding mind-moments that contribute to succeeding ones by making room for the latter to arise.  This 22nd puts emphasis on the fact that the conditioning phenomena are absent when the conditioned phenomena arise.

4.      The 23rd condition, Disappearance Condition (Vigata-paccayo), also emphasizes the fact that the preceding mind-moments disappear when they contribute to their succeeding ones.   

5.      The 9th condition partly comes under this Continuity Condition by the name of Anantarūpanissayo.

Note: Therefore, the five conditions such as Continuity, Absolute Continuity, Absence, Disappearance, Strong Dependence always come together. The Repetition Condition is added to them when they deal with javana.  Thus, these six conditions always come together.   

 


 

6. CO-NASCENCE CONDITION

 

What Co-nascence Condition Means

Co-nascence Condition is all about psychophysical interactions. We are neither eternal souls (jīva-atta) nor creations of god or goddess (parama-atta) but constant psychophysical interactions. Just like fragile threads that become very strong when twisted together into a rope, mental and physical phenomena become powerful by arising together and supporting to one another by means of co-nascence condition (psychophysical interactions).

According to science, for example, smiling has been clinically shown to lower blood pressure, boost immunity, and even release natural painkillers (endorphins). This can help lower stress, boosts happiness, and improve overall health. Apparently, a genuine smile comes along with wholesome mental states led by happiness. So, it is reasonable to assume that wholesome mental states and physical smile are working together to bring us blissful results by means of Co-nascence Condition. Similarly, negative physical behavior like hostile looks, angry shouting, etc., are related to unwholesome mental states, and they are working together to bring us unhealthy results. Over the time, such psychophysical interactions make us totally different from who we were.  This means that we are mutated (saṅkhāra), but not created. Thus, the Co-nascence Condition is all about psychophysical interactions.

 

The Literal Explanation of the Co-nascence Condition

 

  1. Under this Condition, the psychophysical phenomena are classified into five aggregates: matter, feeling, perception, mental formation (or working aggregate) and consciousness. Among them the last four are mental aggregates; they are mutually supportive to one another by means of Co-nascence Condition.
  2. There are four great physical elements that belong to the aggregate of matter: earth, fire, water and wind. They always arise together and are mutually supportive to one another by means of Co-nascence Condition. 
  3. At the moment of conception of five-aggregate beings (like human and animals), the sub-conscious mental states (bhavaṅga and cetasika) and heart-base (hadaya) arise together, and are mutually supportive to one another by means of Co-nascence Condition. 
  4. Minds and their concomitant mental factors are supportive to their mind-born matter by means of Co-nascence Condition (but not mutually).
  5. The four great elements (earth, fire, water and wind) are supportive to their dependent matter by means of Co-nascence Condition (but not mutually).
  6. It is only at the moment of conception, but not during the lifetime that the particular mind (in this case, sub-consciousness) and matter (in this case the heart-base) are mutually related by means of Co-nascence Condition. (It just emphasizes the No.3)

Additional Information

Five Aggregates: Now, we need to take note here of the five aggregates (khandha), as mind and matter are described by the names of aggregates (khandha) under this Paṭṭhāna condition. Below are the Five Aggregates:

1.      Matter Aggregate (Rūpa-kkhandha): It mainly constitutes of 18 physical phenomena: 4 primary elements, 4 objects, 5 senses, 2 gender, nutriment, heart-materiality, physical vitality.

2.      Feeling (Vedana-kkhandha): It constitutes five kinds of feeling: comfort, discomfort, happiness, unhappiness and neutral feeling.

3.       Perception Aggregates (Sañña-kkhandha): The perception is a mental factor that often represents our memory and intellectual knowledge. Here a question to pose is how a single factor (like feeling and perception) constitutes a particular aggregate. The literal explanation here is that a single mental factor constitutes the particular aggregate because it has several different classifications: whether present, past or future, whether internal or external, whether gross or subtle, whether superior or inferior, and whether far or near.

4.      Working Aggregate (Saṅkhāra-kkhandha): It is constituted of 50 mental factors. This term is normally translated as the aggregate of mental formation, but the word ‘Saṅkhāra’ literally means ‘working’. For example, a car is what actually runs on the road, but the driver is responsible for that. In the same way, our bodies are actually working on all actions, but 50 mental factors (led by intention, cetanā) are always behind the working bodies. So, they are called ‘Working Aggregate’.

5.      Consciousness Aggregate (Viññãṇa-kkhandha): As said in Numerical Discourse, consciousness is also single mental phenomenon in terms of cognitive state, but it classified into 89 as follows:

 

How is the single consciousness classified into 89?

·         Greed-rooted Mind (lobha-mūla) is classified into 8 by whether prompted or unprompted, whether associated with happy or neutral feeling, whether associated with illusion or not. 

·         Hate-rooted Mind into two (dosa-mūla) by whether prompted or unprompted.

·         Delusion-rooted Mind (moha-mūla) into 2 by whether associated with doubt or agitation-and-regret. 

·         Rootless Mind (a-hetuka) into 18 by different mental functions such as seeing, hearing, receiving, and so on.

·         Great Moral Mind (mahā-kusala) into 8 by whether prompted or unprompted, whether associated with happy or neutral feeling, whether associated with wisdom or not.

·         Great Resultant Mind (mahā-vipāka) into 8 by its corresponding Great Moral Mind.

·         Great Functional Mind (mahā-kriyā) into 8 in the same way as Great Moral Mind.

·         Fine-material Sphere Mind (rūpā-vacara) into 5 by five sets of jhānic factors.

·         Immaterial Sphere Mind (a-rūpā-vacara) into 4 by four different meditative objects

·         Supra-mundane (lokuttara) into 8 by different degree of enlightenment.

 

 

7. MUTUALITY CONDITION

  1. The four immaterial (i.e., mental) aggregates are mutually supportive to one another by means of Mutuality Condition.
  2. The four great primaries are mutually supportive to one another by the force of Mutuality Condition.
  3. At the moment of conception mentality and materiality are mutually supportive to one another by the force of Mutuality Condition.

 

Note: This Mutuality Condition is equivalent to 1-3 of the Co-nascence Condition.

 

8. DEPENDENCE CONDITION

 (1 to 5 are not translated, as they are all the same as those of the co-nascence condition.)

6. Eye-base is supportive of eye-consciousness-element and its concomitant mental factors by means of the Dependence Condition. (The same is true with the remaining sense-consciousnesses).

7. Dependent on whatever (physical) matter, there arise mind-element and mind-consciousness-element. That matter is supportive of those mind-elements, mind-consciousness-element and their concomitant mental factors by means of Dependence Condition.

Note: Number 1 to 5 are all the same as those of the Co-nascence Condition, while 6 to 7 are the same as those of the Pre-nascence Condition that will be explained later.

 


 

Questions & Answers

 

1.      To reach the first progressive stage (stream-enterer) culminating in full enlightenment asan Arahat, do we have to give up the Bodhisattva vow for Buddhahood to achieve it? 

Unless we give up Bodhisatta vow, we cannot attain even the first stage of enlightenment (stream-enterer) in this lifetime because we have to take certain length of period to fulfill pāramī required for the Buddhahood like certain kinds of tree won’t bear any fruit before certain period of time. But we can develop progressive vipassana insight up to the 11th stage called saṅkhārupekkhā-ñāṇa if we were born with three roots including wisdom.

 

2.      To accomplish or in an attempt to fulfill our wishes, can the power of our past meritorious deeds be activated and bring us the results here and now?

Yes, it can, for sure. We can channel our past merit into this lifetime with the help of merit we have been doing in the present. Suppose, for example, you spend the whole week developing metta wishing all living beings to be happy and healthy. When you really feel pure love for all living beings, then you can make a wish. First, you describe what you wish for, and then you utter thus: “The merit I’ve ever done before, and the merit I’ve just done right now, may both help my wish be fulfilled.” Leave no doubt, your wish will be fulfilled for sure. Of course, the wish you make should be something wholesome and possible to be fulfilled.

 

3.      Emperor Asoka's last moment had the grief-associated mental states on his deathbed, he was reborn as a snake. We have heard many stories when addressing the rebirth process, a snake is the most popular example being born, is it culture-related belief in India?

We can put it this way: People of those days in India had high opinion of a snake (nāga); they thought snakes belonged to celestial realm. Even in modern India, snakes are still popular. So, peoples might have been allured by the life of a snake. Most probably, that attachment would lead them to the rebirth as snakes.

 

4.      Why Asoka's story stresses that it is dosa, rather than moha, causing rebirth in animal realm?

A snake has angry temperament. Most probably, dosa (passive anger in this particular case) is to be blamed for his rebirth as a snake. 

 

5.      You stated in our last class that Kammas is the most important belief a Buddhist should believe. What is your view of Darwinian evolution that the survival of the fittest takes it all at all costs?

 

Actually, I stated in our last class that if we don’t accept life after death (the round of rebirths), then all the Buddha’s teachings would be meaningless. If there is no life after death, kamma itself will be meaningless, too. Moreover, arahants accumulate no kamma (good or bad) at all, because they have no life after death.

 

“Evolution”, to my understanding, refers to the theory that minute microorganisms were progressively evolved into intelligent human. According to Buddha’s teachings, the non-living things are originally generated and gradually mutated into several different forms by the fire element (temperature). So, under certain temperature certain landscapes can be seen and certain kinds of trees and plants grow well and bear fruits. As for living beings, our bodies are originally generated by our kamma, and gradually mutated into what we are now by our mind, the weather we live in and the food we eat, on top of the kamma we have accumulated.

 

Suppose, for example, the giraffes in Africa have long necks probably because their ancestors craved for leaves from tall trees, and thus their necks are gradually mutated into the size we can see today. For polar bears a white color is helpful for hunting in the snow. This might be the reason why their ancestors craved being white, and they are gradually mutated into white ones. According to Dependent Origination, such mutations are powered mainly by two kinds of mental energies: taṇhā (craving for life) and kamma. Nobody on earth wants to die. This means everybody is craving for life. This craving is the mental energy that originally creates a form of life. However, whether a life is blissful or woeful is determined by our good or bad kamma. According to the law of kamma, therefore, an intelligent human can be reborn as a less intelligent being like a dog or cat, and vice versa. Thus, there are countless up-and-down changes throughout the cycle of rebirths. From the Buddhist perspectives these changes may be interpreted as mutation (saṅkhata) rather than as evolution.

 

Anyhow, the answer to your question is we need good kamma to be the fittest who can survive and take it all at all cost.

 

6.      We have encountered many texts in the Mahayana sutras where Buddha's disciples often were scolded by Buddha. These interpretations convey the idea that Mahayana as a more devotional, lay-influenced and lay-inspired form of Buddhism, there are not many parallels found in the Theravada sutras. Please share your view on it.

 

 

As a matter of fact, the Buddha never scolded his disciples, but admonished them by giving the proper guidance to discipline them.

 

According to the events that took place during the Buddha’s lifetime, there were individuals, monastic and lay, who argued against the Buddha as in the case when the Buddha laid down a rule to forbid monks from eating dinner. On the other hand, there were cases the Buddha used strong words to admonish his disciples. For example, when Venerable Piṇḍola showed his supernatural power in public the Buddha denounced him by comparing him to a shameless woman who shows her private body part just for small amount of money. In such cases the Buddha used strong words just because he wanted his disciples to understand how serious certain mistakes were.