CONTINUALITY CONDITION

The Continuality Condition deals with mental processes, in which each and every preceding mind-moment serves as a condition for its immediately succeeding one by means of Continuity Condition. To understand this condition, therefore, it is necessary to learn three kinds of mental process:

1. Sub-consciousness Process

‘Sub-consciousness’ is the consciousness we were born with. So, it represents our heredity like DNA or genes in the cognitive field. But it never reacts to sense-objects in current lifetime. So, it can't be described as good (kusala) or bad (akusala), but as an indeterminate mind-state (abyākata).  This sub-consciousness, flowing constantly throughout our life, can be regarded as a host, and all remaining kinds of mental states as visitors in the cognitive field. Within its constant flow, the preceding sub-consciousness is a condition for the succeeding one. So, it is said: “Preceding indeterminate minds serve as a condition for succeeding ones.”

2. Five-sense-door Process

The five-sense-door process is of five kinds: seeing process, etc.  According to Abhidhamma, our senses have been newly arising and disappearing continuously since the 11th week of our lives in our mother’s womb.  They are called doors because it is through them that the objects (sight, etc.,) come into our mind. For example, a sight comes into our mind through the eye-door, and arouses the mental process of seeing as follows:

1.     Passing sub-consciousness (indeterminate)
2.     Shaking sub-consciousness (indeterminate) 
3.     Terminating sub-consciousness (indeterminate) 
4.     Five-sense-door-examiner or advertence consciousness (indeterminate)
5.     Seeing consciousness (indeterminate) [hearing, smelling, etc.] 
6.     Receiving consciousness (indeterminate) 
7.     Investigating consciousness (indeterminate)  
8.     Determining consciousness (indeterminate)  
9.     Seven moments of fully active consciousness (javana) that is associated with wholesome or unwholesome mental factors depending on one’s mindset (wholesome, unwholesome and functional)
10.      Two moments of registering consciousness (indeterminate)

 

In this process, each and every preceding mind-moment is a condition for its immediately succeeding one. Thus there come three factors as follows:

a.     Conditioning Factors: Preceding Mind-moments

b.     Conditioned Factors: Succeeding Mind-moments

c.      Conditioning Mode: By means of continuation

 

3. Mind-door Process
 
The five-sense-door processes are always followed by many subsequent mind-door processes (tadanuvattika-manodvāra) recalling past memories (of name, etc.) to identify the object. There are also other kinds of mind-door processes that take place when a mind-object[1] comes through our sub-consciousness. Both kinds of mind-door processes are what we call “thoughts”. Their processes are as follows:
 
1.     Shaking sub-consciousness (abyākata )
2.     Terminating sub-consciousness (abyākata)
3.     Examining consciousness (abyākata) 
4.     Fully active consciousness (javana) that often repeats seven times, fully experiencing the sense-object. It can be wholesome or unwholesome (kusala or a-kusala) according to our mind-set.  
5.     Two registering mind-moments that complete the process.

Millions of such mental processes appear and disappear within a split second. So, one moment of our thoughts involves millions of these mental processes. In these processes each and every mind-moment serves as a condition for its immediately succeeding one by means of Continuity Condition.

 


 

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

 

Four Kinds of Density

According to the Continuity Condition, mental processes are so continuous and so dense that it is almost impossible for us to see mental phenomena distinctively, and their conditionality and impermanence, etc. Here, the processes are dense (ghana) in four ways: dense in process (santati), dense in formation (samūha), dense in function (kicca), and dense in object (ārammaṇa). Such massive mental processes make us feel as if we have been the same persons thinking from the day we were born until now[2].

 

Six Kinds of Mental Legacy

Moreover, such dense mental processes in nature carry along with them the dormant forms of mental energies (mental legacies) from one mind-moment to another and from one life to another. They are of six kinds:

1.     Kamma: Good or bad luck created by good or bad intention that is the driving force behind all our actions.

2.     Anusaya: Seven bad mental tendencies left by seven bad mental states, viz., craving for sensual pleasure, craving for life, hatred, conceit, illusion, skeptical doubt, and ignorance.

3.     Pāramī: Ten good mental qualities left by ten good mental states, viz., generosity, morality, renunciation, wisdom, effort, patience, truthfulness, resolution, loving kindness, and equanimity.

4.     Ajjhāsaya: liking and disliking left by our judgment of the objects we encounter.

5.     Vāsanā: Good or bad habitual tendencies left by our repeated actions

6.     Cārita: Good or bad mentality left by our overwhelming thoughts.  

                                                                                                         

                                     

PATTHANA QUESTIONS

 

1.      What is the Conditioning Mode, is it part of the ultimate phenomena or a concept?

 

It is part of the ultimate phenomena. For instance, greed performs as the root of stealing. This performance is the Conditioning Mode of the greed, part of the greed.

 

2.      There are six kinds of mental legacy mentioned in Continuity Condition which lie dormant in our mental process and are related to our experiences in past lives, where is the source of this reference? 

 

These mental legacies cannot be found all together in a single sutta. However, there are many different suttas and stories that indicate how the would-be-Buddha fulfilled pāramī, and how someone was born with good or bad luck, good or bad mentality and tendency. In the Mahā-nāma Sutta, for example, the Buddha evidently said that one’s mental qualities remain behind (as mental legacies) although one’s physical bodies is eaten up by wild animals and insects on one’s demise. Please refer to Mahā-nāma Sutta-1, Mahā-vagga Samyutta (B. Bodhi’s translation 1808- 1809).

 

3.      Please clarify the differences among the last three of the mental legacies from the preceding question: liking and disliking, tendencies, and mentality.

 

Liking and disliking (ajjhāsaya) may be explained by the story of two Burmese girls in a remote village, who liked European diet instead of Burmese diet because they had been two British pilots during the WWII, and shot down in the area near the village where they were born.  Tendency (vāsanā) here refers to habitual behavior left by one’s repeated actions. And "mentality" (carita) means the characteristic attitude of mind, e.g., the criminal mentality.

 

4.      Can preceding wholesome states serve as a condition for succeeding unwholesome states by the force of Continuity Condition and vice versa?

 

No, because the Continuity Condition refers to every mind-moment, which always contributes to the mind-moment that succeeds it immediately.  Wholesome and unwholesome never succeed each other immediately; there are always, at least, sub-conscious moments in between.

 

5.      Is our memories based completely in our brain, or something beyond the brain attributing to our experiences in past lives?

 

There are undeniable tales told by children who can remember their past life events, which prove that there is something beyond our brains in our current lives.

 

6.      Scientists propose theories by careful observation of various experiences and then test out theories by further experiments.  Science and Buddhism are in different domains and need not to be combined except for the unimportant, oft-quoted and inadequate part when Buddhism tries to describe natural events.   The important part of Buddhism is to deal with human feelings, thinking, actions. What is your point of view on this? 

 

Science only accepts the present life; the current body and brain represent who we are.  The Buddhism accepts lives before and after this life, and deals with the interactions of body and mind, including our feelings, thoughts, actions, etc. For sure, the Buddhism puts emphasis on mind and the science on brain and genes. Even then, science found that brain has plasticity and can be reshaped by the mind, and that the tune of DNA (genetic processes) is played by the epigenetic processes (chemical reactions), which is more or less related to the mind, too. So, it’s still sensible to take the mind as a key factor in our lives according to the Buddha’s teachings.

 

 

 

Below is from TWINS, an article in National Geographic, Jan., 2012

Epigenetic Processes, i.e., the chemical reactions are related to neither nature nor nurture but representing what researchers called a “third component”. These reactions influence how our genetic code is expressed: how each gene is strengthened or weakened, even turned on or off, to build our bones, brains, and all the other parts of our bodies.

If we think of our DNA as an immense piano keyboard and our genes as keys—each key symbolizing a segment of DNA responsible for a particular note, or trait, and all the keys combining to make us who we are—then epigenetic processes determine when and how each key can be struck, changing the tune of being played.

Studies of animals, for example, have shown that when a rat experiences stress during pregnancy, it can cause epigenetic changes in a fetus that lead to behavioral problems as the rodent grows up.

 

 



[1] Mind-object refers to all the objects that can come into our mind-stream only through sub-consciousness but not with five senses. It includes all mental and physical phenomena, conceptual objects and nibbana.

[2] Note: According to this Continuity Condition, there is no interim life between the past life and the current one because the last mind-moment (cuti) of the past life was immediately succeeded by the first mind-moment (paṭisandhi) of the current life by the force of Continuity Condition.