Dear U Hla Myint:
Here are the summary of our 6/22 questions:
1. The feeling aggregate has five kinds listed as comfort, discomfort, happiness, unhappiness and neutral feeling) which are quite different from the standard classifications (bodily pleasure, bodily pain, mental joy, mental grief and equanimity). Please clarify.
Comfort and discomfort are equivalent to bodily pleasure and bodily pain, respectively. And happiness and unhappiness are the same as mental joy and mental grief, respectively. But "neutral feeling" is a good translation for upekkha-vedana. The Pali word, "upekkha" literally means "seeing things evenly (i.e., without bias)"; it is the mental state balanced between two extremes. It is of ten kinds, such as chalanga-upekkha, brahmavihara-upekkha, and so on.. So, we cannot find a single English word equivalent to it. So, we have to translate upekkha according to the context. For example, chalanga-upekkha is translated as "Six-factored Equanimity" that refers to the Arahants' stabile mind because the arahant's mind is not afflicted by any of the six objects whether pleasant or unpleasant. And brahmavihara-upekkha is translated as "Divine Abiding Equanimity" referring to the mental state that keeps our mind without a bias against or in favor of any living being. In the case of feeling, I rather translate upekkha as "neutral feeling" according to the context because the English word "equanimity" itself does not really mean feeling, but calmness of mind or temper. For ten kinds of upekkha, please refer to Visuddhi-magga (Chapter IV, 156).
2. You classify 89 kinds of consciousness by Jati (characteristic of cognizing, profitable, etc) whereas "The Path of Purification" and "A Comprehensive Manual of Abhidhamma" reference 89 kinds by bhumi (plane into the sense sphere, fine-material sphere, etc.). Please share the pros and cons of both ways.
If the consciousness were classified by bhumi alone, it would be of just four kinds: kama, rupa, arupa and lokuttara. Or it might be 31 kinds because there are 31 planes. Actually, different consciousness is classified not only by planes, but many different mental factors. For example, the greed-associated consciousness is classified into eight depending on whether it is with happy or unhappy feeling, with illusion or conceit, and with prompted or unprompted. In the case of jhana, for example, the consciousness is classified by jhanic factors and wholesome, resultant, and functional. So, in one case the classification may be mentioned by jati, but in other cases it may be by plane and so on. It is just to give a reader the general idea of classification.
3. Please differentiate the differences between two kinds of delusion-rooted consciousness: ignorance and delusional.
Two delusion-rooted minds: The first one is associated with vicikiccha (skeptical doubt), and the second is with uddhacca (discursive thought or wondering mind).
4. Redundant phrases noticed in the explanation of the Co-Nascence Condition when illustrating how four mental aggregates relate to each other mutually.
That is literal explanation.
5. Theravada school explains the rebirths from one life to another by the force of Continuity condition, please share the other schools' (Mahayana, Tibetan) concept.
In other schools the concept of reincarnation seem to refer to something like eternal soul that transmigrate from one life to another, but the Theravada school very vividly emphasizes that there is only dense psycho-physical process, but not anything eternal that transmigrates from one life to another.
6. The Tibetan school uses the power of sharing merits to re-divert the preceding wholesomeness from turning into unwholesome states by the force of the Strong-dependent Condition. Is there any remedy practiced by the Theravada school?
All the Buddhist schools have this doctrine in common.
Best Regards,